The Municipality of Anchorage, the APDEA, And The 4/10 Dispute

November 24, 1999

Mayor Takes Police Fight To Chamber
Public Pays For $900 Flier

By Don Hunter
Daily News reporter

Mayor Rick Mystrom is spending public money for a brochure promoting his side of a work schedule confrontation with Anchorage police.

A three-page brochure giving Mystrom's arguments about why he thinks an arbitrator erred in awarding police millions of dollars in compensation was sent this week to about 1,200 people on an Anchorage Chamber of Commerce mailing list.

"We have an obligation to get information out," Mystrom said Tuesday.

Spokesman Sherman Ernouf said the mayor is trying to counter thousands of dollars in newspaper and radio advertising paid for by the Anchorage Police Department Employees Association. The mayor's brochure cost about $900, Ernouf said.

Police union President Rob Heun said the APDEA only started running its ads to counter Mystrom's political influence and his access to the press.

"The mayor was using his bully pulpit, and nobody was hearing our perspective," he said.

The brochure provoked grumbling among some Anchorage Assembly members who questioned the use of taxpayer's money to sway public opinion on an issue Mystrom already has appealed to court.

"It would be my hope they don't get into an advertising war over this," said Assemblyman Dan Sullivan. "The courts are going to resolve it."

The dispute goes back to 1994, when Mystrom unilaterally ordered police to change from a four-day, 10-hour workweek to a five-day, eight-hour shift. Union officials said the move violated their labor contract, and an independent arbitrator agreed with them last year. The city and union had agreed that the arbitrator's decision would be binding.

In a second decision last month, the same arbitrator ruled that the city must compensate officers for the loss of free time. Mystrom says that could cost up to $4 million in overtime.

Police have offered to take paid time off to help reduce the cost of the arbitrator's decision, but Mystrom says that would take officers off the street and add overtime costs for others. H has appealed the decision in court, against the advice of an Assembly public safety committee.

Mystrom and the APDEA accuse each other of distorting the facts.

"We needed to correct all the misinformation," Mystrom said in explaining his decision to mail out the flier.

Heun said labor documents and the arbitrator's decisions show it's Mystrom whose facts need correcting. The rulings and other documents about the case are available on the APDEA's Internet web site (www.alaska.net/~apdea), he said.

The union's ad campaign, including radio spots and several full-page newspaper ads, has cos about $30,000, Heun said.

"We tried keeping a respectful silence for a long time," he said. "We stayed within the agreed-upon process every step of the way, but the mayor wasn't satisfied with the arbitrator's (decision)."

Ernouf said there are no current plans for additional brochures or advertising, but Mystrom said that could change.

"We're talking about it and watching what they're doing," the mayor said.

* Reporter Don Hunter can be reached at dhunter@adn.com. Reporter Elizabeth Manning contributed to this story.

HISTORY AND DOCUMENTATION

The History Of The 4/10 Dispute
 Arbitration Decisions APD's Original Analysis Of The 4/10 Issue
 The Municipality's Claimed $400,000 Annual Savings From Ending The 4/10 Shift The APDEA's Briefs On The Appropriate Remedy
 APDEA Settlement Offer The Mayor's Rejection Of The APDEA's
Settlement Offer

Anchorage Speaks Out! Related Links